Web Analytics Made Easy - Statcounter

Goodbye Pie: After a decade on Anastasia Boulevard, popular pizza joint announces closure date

Updated on:

Share this post :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Restaurant bar area
The current interior of the Mellow Mushroom. (Mellow Mushroom)

Mellow Mushroom has officially announced the closing date for its Anastasia Boulevard location, confirming that its final day of service will be Tuesday, November 18.

In a message to customers, the restaurant wrote: “The rumors are true… Just because this chapter is done doesn’t mean the story is over. Don’t count us out just yet, St. Augustine. There are many more chapters to come.”

The announcement marks a major step in the transition of a business that has spent more than a decade anchoring the vibrant Anastasia Boulevard corridor.

Florida restaurant exterior.
The Mellow Mushroom is on the move. (Google Maps)

Over the years, the restaurant has served locals, tourists, and beachgoers alike, becoming known for its colorful, psychedelic aesthetic and laid-back atmosphere.

As first reported in The Citizen, the building itself is now on the market. The 5,770-square-foot freestanding structure sits on approximately 0.42 acres and is listed for $3.75 million. That listing is still active.

The current zoning allows for a variety of commercial possibilities beyond restaurant use, including retail or entertainment.

The structure includes a full commercial kitchen with hoods, a grease trap, walk-in cooler and freezer, prep areas, a large open dining room, bar seating, private event space, restrooms, and signage with two-direction access from Anastasia Boulevard.

Mellow Mushroom previously stated that it is developing a new nearby site,

Founded in 1974 in Atlanta, the brand has long been known for its uniquely designed, locally operated locations throughout the Southeast.

Share this post :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
St Johns Citizen Logo

Newsletter

Sign up for breaking updates, exclusive stories, and community events.

Newsletter

Sign up for breaking updates, exclusive stories and community events.